Detroit ‘Grand Bargain’ vote key to bankruptcy end

Comment: Off

Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder introduces Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan before signing legislation to provide state funding for Detroit municipal pensions as part of city’s bankruptcy process during a ceremony at the refurbished Globe Building in Detroit, Friday, June 20, 2014. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)

Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder introduces Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan before signing legislation to provide state funding for Detroit municipal pensions as part of city’s bankruptcy process during a ceremony at the refurbished Globe Building in Detroit, Friday, June 20, 2014. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)

Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder shows off the legislation he signed which will provide state funding for Detroit municipal pensions as part of city’s bankruptcy process during a ceremony at the refurbished Globe Building in Detroit, Friday, June 20, 2014. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)

FILE- In a June 9, 2014 file photo, Gerald Rosen, Chief U.S. District judge holds up a note as he speaks in front of part of Diego Rivera’s Detroit Industry mural at the Detroit Institute of Arts in Detroit. An offer of help following a chance meeting during Detroit’s historic bankruptcy led to an unprecedented coming together of deep-pocketed philanthropies whose money _ and desire _ could contribute to the city’s resurrection from insolvency. Mariam Noland, Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan, made the offer last summer at a downtown Detroit deli to Rosen, who called her on it. A few months later more than a dozen local and national foundations bought in and made a $365 million promise that is one-third of a so-called Grand Bargain valued over time at $816 million. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, FILE)

FILE- In a June 9, 2014 file photo, Kevyn Orr, Detroit Emergency Manager, from left, Eugene Gargaro Jr., Detroit Institute Of Arts chairman of the board, and Gerald Rosen, chief U.S. district judge listen during a news conference at the Detroit Institute of Arts in Detroit. An offer of help following a chance meeting during Detroit’s historic bankruptcy led to an unprecedented coming together of deep-pocketed philanthropies whose money _ and desire _ could contribute to the city’s resurrection from insolvency. Mariam Noland, Community Foundation for Southeast Michigan, made the offer last summer at a downtown Detroit deli to Rosen, who called her on it. A few months later more than a dozen local and national foundations bought in and made a $365 million promise that is one-third of a so-called Grand Bargain valued over time at $816 million. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya, FILE)

Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder shows off the legislation he signed which will provide state funding for Detroit municipal pensions as part of city’s bankruptcy process during a ceremony at the refurbished Globe Building in Detroit, Friday, June 20, 2014. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)

Buy AP Photo Reprints

DETROIT (AP) — An effort by deep-pocketed philanthropists to save the bankrupt city of Detroit’s art treasures began with a chance meeting last year and culminated Friday when Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder signed a bill authorizing millions in state help.

But all parties excited about the bill signing know that work could be for naught if the city’s pensioners and workers, who are nearing a deadline for a historic vote on Detroit’s plan to get out of bankruptcy, reject what has been dubbed the Grand Bargain.

“It is really not in our hands,” said Rip Rapson, president of the Kresge Foundation, which has pledged $100 million toward the plan. “We fully understand that the pensioners have to make very hard decisions as to whether this is something they can support.”

The state’s contribution of $195 million, along with $366 million from foundations and a $100 million pledge from the Detroit Institute of Arts, would replace hundreds of millions being cut from retiree pensions, while stopping bond insurers and other creditors from forcing the sell-off of city-owned art such as Van Gogh’s “Self Portrait.” The money would come over 20 years, placing the value at about $816 million.

As part of the deal, the artwork will go into a charitable trust.

Retirees and city workers have until July 11 to vote on the proposal, which is included in state-appointed emergency manager Kevyn Orr’s plan for Detroit’s restructuring. The city filed for the largest municipal bankruptcy in history last summer, and a trial on the restructuring is set for August. Orr has said he hopes to have Detroit out of bankruptcy by the end of this summer.

“This huge amount of resources is not there if they vote ‘no,’ and they’re much worse off financially,” Snyder said Friday. “By voting ‘yes,’ they are going to be taking sacrifices, but hopefully they’ve been reduced dramatically from what they otherwise would have been, and it’s something that will allow the city to come back faster and better.”

In May, Orr said early ballots showed workers and retirees supporting the plan by about 2 to 1. His spokesman, Bill Nowling, said Thursday that they cannot release detailed numbers, but “are encouraged by the voting activity.”

The 32,000 retirees and current and former city workers would see base pension cuts of no more than 4.5 percent under the plan instead of as much as 26 percent. Despite pressure to vote yes, some retirees insist that bankruptcy should not be a reason to break the state constitutional protections of public pensions. They would prefer to take the fight to a higher court, even if Detroit is broke and the pension funds are struggling.

Retiree Mary Highgate, who plans to return her ballot July 1, believes Orr’s plan will proceed regardless of the vote result.

“Everybody I know is voting ‘no’ because we don’t trust them,” said Highgate, 69. “I’m voting No! No! No!”

The financial contributions from the foundations, state and museum also mean little to her because Highgate doubts that concern for retirees is the true motivation.

“All they care about is the art,” she said. “Do you really think they care about the little people? Have they ever?”

The philanthropic support may never

Comments

comments

About the Author